Blog

Gumloop vs n8n vs Make: Which AI automation tool fits your business?

You want to research leads, sort support emails, or pull invoice details into a spreadsheet. You could do it yourself. You could also spend the weekend building an automation that saves you ten minutes on Monday.

Choosing the right tool helps avoid the second outcome.

Gumloop, n8n, and Make let you connect business apps and use AI within those processes. The differences come down to how you build, how much control you need, and who fixes things when a run fails.

Gumloop, n8n and Make workflows comparing three ways to turn a lead enquiry into a CRM record.

Update, October 2026: This article previously compared Gumloop, Relay.app, and Lindy. Relay.app shut down in September 2026, and its team deleted accounts, workflows, and run history. The comparison now focuses on active tools.

The quick comparison

Gumloopn8nMake
Worth considering forManaged AI agents that work across your business toolsCustom workflows, code, and control over hostingVisual workflows connecting business apps
Building approachAgent instructions, connected tools, and triggersVisual nodes with optional JavaScript or PythonVisual scenarios with modules, filters, and routes
HostingManaged serviceManaged cloud or your own infrastructureManaged service
Cost structurePaid plans with AI credits and an orchestration feePaid plans based on workflow executions, plus a self-hosted Community EditionFree plan and paid tiers based on credits

These are starting points for choosing a tool. You still need to check whether it supports the particular action you want in each app.

Gumloop: building agents around business tasks

Gumloop now puts agents at the centre of its product. You give an agent instructions, connect your tools, and use app triggers or recurring tasks to start work.

For a sales team, that could mean researching a prospect and preparing information for a CRM update. For a content team, it could mean gathering material and drafting a brief for review. You need to define the task and check the output before trusting it with customer records or published content.

Gumloop also provides an agent browser. Agents can click, fill forms, and retrieve information from websites, including sites without an API. You can take over the browser when an agent needs a login or approval. That's relevant if part of your process depends on a website rather than a supported connector.

The older visual workflow builder remains in the product, but Gumloop labels workflows as legacy on its pricing page. Keep that in mind when following tutorials built around the old canvas.

Gumloop is worth considering if you want a hosted agent service and expect AI to handle a substantial part of the work. Its paid plans include credits, with an orchestration fee in the cost structure. Check the cost of a representative task before committing to a busy recurring job.

n8n: more control, more responsibility

With n8n, you build workflows on a visual canvas and add code where you need it. You can make custom API requests, connect AI models, and inspect the inputs and outputs of individual steps.

That suits work with awkward data or requirements that don't fit a standard app connector. You might extract fields from an invoice with AI, validate them with rules, then ask someone to approve the next action. n8n supports human approval for AI tool calls. You don't have to give an agent unrestricted access to complete the process.

You can use n8n's hosted service or run it on your own infrastructure. Self-hosting gives you control over the deployment, but you take on updates and backups. And sending data to an external AI provider still means sending it outside your server.

For an indie hacker comfortable with APIs, n8n is a sensible starting point. For a small business without anyone willing to maintain the setup, the hosted version deserves a look before you start renting servers.

On paid plans, n8n counts workflow executions: a run of the whole workflow rather than a charge for each step. AI provider costs and other paid services can add to that bill. The self-hosted Community Edition also leaves you with infrastructure costs and maintenance work.

Make: mapping the process between your apps

Make lets you build visual scenarios from connected modules. You can add filters and routes to send records through different branches of a process. It also supports AI agents and AI model connections.

Consider a lead form. You want to check the submission, add a contact to your CRM, and notify someone in Slack. You can map those steps in Make and add AI where you need to interpret free text, such as classifying the enquiry.

I'd put Make on the shortlist for a small business with an existing collection of apps and a process it can describe step by step. Check the connector's supported actions first. Finding your CRM in an integration list doesn't guarantee access to the field or action you need.

Make has a free plan and paid tiers. It bills in credits, which module actions consume. Some AI features use more credits than standard actions. A scenario that loops through a pile of records can consume much more than its diagram suggests.

Put AI where you need interpretation

You can mix fixed rules and AI in the same workflow.

Use a rule to check whether an invoice total exceeds your approval threshold. Use AI to extract the total from a supplier's PDF. Ask a person to review ambiguous results before you update accounting records.

For support emails, AI can suggest a category or draft a reply. You can keep the routing rules explicit and require approval before sending. Start with drafts while you check how it handles your customers' questions.

Lindy and Zapier

Lindy remains another option for delegating work through an assistant interface. It supports interaction through Slack, iMessage, and a browser. It's outside the main comparison here.

Zapier also supports AI workflows and agents. If you already use it, check whether you can build the process there before taking on another subscription.

Choose with one real workflow

Start with Gumloop if you want to build managed agents around tasks across your business tools. Consider n8n if you need custom logic or control over hosting. Try Make if you want to map a process between the apps you use.

Build one workflow using real data before moving more work into it. Include an incomplete record and an input that should require human review. Check the run history, the output, and the cost.

Keep a copy of your prompts and document the connections and approval steps. Relay's shutdown is a reason to make rebuilding possible. Your next automation tool should save you work without making your business depend on a process you can no longer explain.